Redistricting commission gives glimpse of Franklin, Hamilton county maps as talks continue

By: - January 21, 2022 3:50 am

Senate President Matt Huffman looks at redistricting map proposals during a recent Ohio Redistricting Commission meeting. (Photo: Susan Tebben, OCJ)

The Ohio Redistricting Commission still hasn’t come to a complete agreement on new district maps ordered by the Ohio Supreme Court.

But the commission gave an update on the process Thursday, after pushing back their meeting time in an attempt to “see if we can come a little closer” to agreement, according to co-chair state Sen. Vernon Sykes, D-Akron.

“The staff has been working on both sides … what’s before the commission right now is not comprehensive,” Sykes said.

Franklin County House districts, as proposed by the Ohio GOP.

The commission is taking a “regional approach” to map-making, according to Sykes, who said he came up with the idea to look at the “building blocks” of the maps statewide, rather than a blanket approach to the entire state.

The Republicans and Democrats released map proposals for four specific counties on Thursday: Franklin, Union, Hamilton and Warren Counties.

House Speaker and commission co-chair Bob Cupp said there has been collaboration between state Republicans and Democrats on the commission, but no agreement quite yet.

The Republican maps were posted to the Ohio Redistricting Commission’s website, and a Democratic “reply” was sent to media for each of the House and Senate maps.

Franklin County Senate districts proposed by the Ohio GOP.

The Republican proposals for the House would have 11 Democratic-leaning districts in Franklin and Union counties and one Republican leaning district, according to numbers provided with the maps. The Senate proposal has four districts leaning Democratic and none leaning Republican in those counties.

In Hamilton and Warren counties, the proposal from the Republicans would lead to five districts in Hamilton County leaning Democratic, and two leaning Republican. Warren County would have two Republican leaning districts in the House, and no Democratic districts.

Districts 27 and 28 could be more like toss-up districts based on GOP numbers, with District 27 having only a 50.1% advantage to the Democrats, and District 28 holding a 51%-48% Dem advantage.

The proposal would result in one Democratic leaning district in the Senate for Hamilton and Warren Counties, with two others leaning Republican.

Franklin County, as proposed by the Ohio Democratic redistricting maps.

The Democrats’ reply has two Democratic leaning districts in the Hamilton County Senate seats, and one that could be a toss-up, with a 49%-48% Democratic advantage.

The House districts in the Democratic Hamilton County proposal would have four Democratic leaning, two Republican, and one (District 27) with a 49%-48% split leaning Dem.

Franklin County’s Senate seats would lean Democratic in three instances, with one district (District 6) holding a 48.95%-48.74% Dem advantage.

The House districts proposed in the Democratic caucuses Franklin County map would have 10 strongly leaning Democrat, one leaning strongly Republican, and one (District 10) split 48.96% to 48.72% with a GOP advantage.

Democratic caucus staffer Chris Glassburn presented the Democratic map proposals, saying the minority party made several concessions to what the GOP asked for, such as extending the Hamilton County districts into Warren County rather than Butler County.

The Ohio Dems Franklin County redistricting proposal.

Glassburn said staff for the Democrats have been putting their heads together to get to map proposals that meet the standards spelled out in the Ohio Constitution and the Ohio Supreme Court order. But he said multiple times during Thursday’s commission meeting that “the other side” has not seen fit to do the same.

Gov. Mike DeWine asked Glassburn if it was clear the two sides were working toward the goal of complying with the supreme court decision, including all of the sections of the constitution regarding redistricting.

“That has not been the instruction that has been expressed by the other map drawers and the other people that we’ve been working with, and that has been a significant obstacle,” Glassburn said.

After the meeting, Cupp said as far as his staff is concerned, fulfilling the supreme court directive was the commitment for the staffers.

“I think there must be some miscommunication somewhere, because the directions to our staff have been to draw district maps that fully comply with the constitutional requirements,” Cupp said.

The commission is working on a Saturday deadline, based on the Ohio Supreme Court order giving them 10 days from the date of the order to complete a new map. The public then has three days to file objections to the maps, which the court will then consider.

The commission also might be looking at congressional maps, which were rejected by the state’s highest court the same week as the legislative maps, and now have to be redone within 30 days. The General Assembly is tasked to correct them within 30 days, a mid-February deadline, but if they can’t come to an agreement, the ORC may be brought in to make that decision as well.

GET THE MORNING HEADLINES DELIVERED TO YOUR INBOX

SUPPORT NEWS YOU TRUST.

Our stories may be republished online or in print under Creative Commons license CC BY-NC-ND 4.0. We ask that you edit only for style or to shorten, provide proper attribution and link to our web site. Please see our republishing guidelines for use of photos and graphics.

Susan Tebben
Susan Tebben

Susan Tebben is an award-winning journalist with a decade of experience covering Ohio news, including courts and crime, Appalachian social issues, government, education, diversity and culture. She has worked for The Newark Advocate, The Glasgow Daily Times, The Athens Messenger, and WOUB Public Media. She has also had work featured on National Public Radio.

MORE FROM AUTHOR