Redistricting commission insults Ohioans by waiting until last minute to meet

February 17, 2022 3:20 am

Ohio Senate President Matt Huffman and Ohio House Speaker Bob Cupp, both Lima Republicans. Official photos.

The contempt majority legislative leaders on the Ohio Redistricting Commission are showing to the public by waiting until the last possible day to draw a third round of Statehouse maps is nothing short of astounding.

The maps they drew in September were ruled by the Ohio Supreme Court to be unconstitutional gerrymanders. Then the second round of maps they presented — working off their previous gerrymandered maps — were also ruled unconstitutional. That was on Feb. 7.

They had 10 days to draw new maps, not based on previous maps. It wasn’t until more than a week later, the night of Feb. 15, they even announced a meeting. They meet today, Thursday, Feb. 17, the same day the maps are due to the Ohio Secretary of State’s Office.

Things got so bad with this meeting that Republican Ohio Auditor Keith Faber sent a letter to Democratic state Sen. Vernon Sykes, the co-chair of the commission, telling him he believes that he had the authority to call a meeting himself, as Republican Ohio House Speaker Bob Cupp, the other co-chair, had not done so. Faber said he had been available to meet since the day the second round of maps were declared unconstitutional.

Sykes noted in his response that the rules adopted by the commission require the co-chairs to jointly call a meeting, adding that he had “repeatedly and continuously indicated the availability of Democrats to meet at any time,” and said that Cupp told him he couldn’t get the Republican majority members of the commission to confirm their availability.

“I find it perplexing that this would be the case considering the seriousness of the situation and the rapidly approaching deadline,” Sykes wrote.

Perplexing indeed, if one is to assume that these Republican majority legislative leaders truly wanted 1.) fair, constitutional districts that don’t rig the game for them to keep their supermajorities, 2.) ample time for public review and input, and 3.) appropriate transparency in a process about which everyone from anti-gerrymandering advocates to the Republican commission members themselves have complained.

In short, it’s only perplexing if you assume these Republican majority legislative leaders are in any way acting in good faith. They are not.

Despite being smacked down twice so far by a bipartisan 4-3 majority on the Ohio Supreme Court, they continue to play political power games, no matter the cost to Ohio’s 2022 election cycle and the public trust — no matter the chaos they inflict by holding their middle fingers up to the more than 71% of Ohio voters who amended the Ohio Constitution to pass anti-gerrymandering reform.

As I wrote in September, Huffman and Cupp on the commission are tasked with drawing the districts of the very caucuses they lead, a huge conflict when it comes to them desiring accurately bipartisan fairness in representation.

Their personal and professional interests are maintaining their leadership and the supermajority strength of their caucuses — essentially their political power — and not drawing mortar fire from their members who’ve been enjoying the fat steak of gerrymander-rigged elections for many years, and would rather not give up their seats to the ideal of a truly representational Republic.

But instead of buckling down and getting to good, honest work as Republican Ohio Supreme Court Justice Maureen O’Connor shot down their gerrymandering attempts not once but twice, Huffman and Cupp have instead been throwing themselves a temper-tantrum pity party trying to place blame on anybody but the men in their own mirrors.

As the editorial board noted, slamming these legislative leaders for their delays Wednesday, while Huffman said last week that, “we’ve got to figure out a way,” he added that “doesn’t change the reality that it doesn’t appear that we can do that, and no one has found a way.”

The way that apparently doesn’t exist in Huffman’s mind is to pass fair maps that actually represent the political makeup of Ohio voters. ‘Seems simple, but not when you’re obsessed with keeping power at all costs in defiance of the voters and in abdication of your duty to uphold the Ohio Constitution.

Meanwhile, as the editorial board also noted, “the commission’s other three Republicans — Gov. Mike DeWine, Auditor Keith Faber and Secretary of State Frank LaRose — have stood around like spectators at a traffic accident, waiting for somebody else, anybody else, to summon ambulances and wreckers.”

This undershoots it quite a bit. DeWine, Faber, and LaRose could’ve supported fair maps either of the two previous times they had the opportunity. Instead they all towed the Huffman/Cupp line and voted for unconstitutionally gerrymandered, partisan maps. That’s not just watching a traffic accident; it’s removing the stop sign that could’ve prevented it.

Moral and ethical cowardice abounds in Ohio’s halls of power. This pathetic charade on an issue so critical to the health of Ohio government is a stark and startling case study in that cowardice.



Our stories may be republished online or in print under Creative Commons license CC BY-NC-ND 4.0. We ask that you edit only for style or to shorten, provide proper attribution and link to our web site. Please see our republishing guidelines for use of photos and graphics.

David DeWitt
David DeWitt

OCJ Editor-in-Chief and Columnist David DeWitt has been covering government, politics, and policy in Ohio since 2007, including education, health care, crime and courts, poverty, state and local government, business, labor, energy, environment, and social issues. He has worked for the National Journal, The New York Observer, The Athens NEWS, and He holds a bachelor’s degree from Ohio University’s E.W. Scripps School of Journalism and is a board member of the E.W. Scripps Society of Alumni and Friends. He can be found on Twitter @DC_DeWitt